Payments & Claims
Payments
Below are links that you can use to make payments.
Claims
Claims can be reported directly to your insurance company or to our office. If you choose to report to the company please choose the link below. If it is a claim involving serious bodily injury or property damage you can reach us after hours: Bruce Chapman 315-576-0731 or Trevor Chapman 585-507-9825.

Adirondack Insurance Exchange
Williamsville, NY
866-992-4368

American Model
Cincinnati, OH
800-759-9008

Allegany Insurance Group
Cuba, NY
800-333-1679

AmTrust Financial
Cleveland, OH
866-272-9267

American Collectors
Cherry Hill, NJ
800-360-2277

Chubb
Whitehouse Station, NJ
800-252-4670

Cincinnati Insurance Companies
Cincinnati, OH
877-242-2544

CNY Surety
Sioux Falls, SD
800-331-6053

Countryway
Syracuse, NY
315-634-5200

Dryden Mutual
Dryden, NY
800-782-0154

Erie and Niagara
Williamsville, NY
716-632-5433

Foremost Insurance Group
Grand Rapids, MI
800-435-7764

Genesee Patrons
Batavia, NY
585-343-7307

Guard
Wilkes-Barre, PA
800-673-2465

Hagerty
Traverse City, MI
800-922-4050

Harleysville
Harleysville, PA
800-338-8301

The Hartford
Hartford, CT
800-327-3636

Hartford Steam
Hartford, CT
800-345-1122

J.C. Taylor
Upper Darby, PA
800-345-8290

Leatherstocking
Cooperstown, NY
800-886-8048

Livingston Mutual
Lititz, PA
855-725-5642

Main Street America
Syracuse, NY
877-425-2467

Merchants
Buffalo, NY
800-462-1077

Midstate Mutual
Auburn, NY
800-826-8520

National Flood
Shawnee Mission, KS
800-637-3846

National General
Winston Salem, NC
800-325-1088

Nationwide
Columbus, OH
800-421-3535

North Country
Watertown, NY
800-847-7030

NYCM Insurance
Edmeston, NY
800-234-6926

Philadelphia
Williamsville, NY
585-394-5482

Preferred Mutual
New Berlin, NY
800-333-7642

Progressive
Cleveland OH
800-274-4499

RLI
DeWitt, NY
800-331-4929

Security Mutual
Ithaca, NY
607-257-5000

Sterling Insurance
Cobbleskill, NY
800-462-4661

Travelers
Hartford, CT
800-252-4633

Travelers Business
Hartford, CT
800-252-2268

Utica National
Utica, NY
800-216-1420

Wayne Cooperative
Clyde, NY
800-724-1648